Top 5 Red Flags of a Weak Workplace Safety Culture and Solutions

A strong safety culture is crucial for a safe and productive workplace, we all know that. But when safety gets pushed aside, it can lead to accidents, injuries, and even worse consequences. Plus, a weak safety culture can be costly for businesses. In an earlier blog post, we looked at what the implications of ignoring workplace safety. If you're seeing these issues pop up, it’s time to take action.

1. Lack of Leadership Buy-In

What It Looks Like: Leaders may put safety policies in place but then fail to follow them themselves, which sends a strong message to employees that safety isn’t a priority. This can lead to a trickle-down effect where employees reflect the same disengagement from leadership. Research shows that safety leadership has a direct impact on safety performance. The more involved leaders are in safety practices, the better the overall safety performance of the company. This leadership influence can result in a 33% improvement in safety outcomes ⁽²⁾.

Why It Matters: When leaders don't prioritize safety, employees will feel less motivated to do the same. This can result in a lax attitude towards safety procedures and an increased risk of accidents and ultimately a workplace safety culture..

How to Fix It:

• Lead by Example: Encourage leadership at all levels to adhere strictly to safety protocols. From the C-suite to front-line supervisors, everyone must visibly commit to safety.
• Invest in Safety Initiatives: Leaders should support safety efforts with time, resources, and incentives, demonstrating their commitment. Regularly highlight the importance of safety during team meetings and company communications.

2. Poor Communication Between Departments or HQ

What It Looks Like:
Ineffective communication between departments can create confusion, misunderstandings, and a lack of unity around safety protocols. A survey by YouGov ⁽³⁾, commissioned by SafetyCulture, found that 40% of frontline workers feel that management is disconnected from their roles based on the messages they receive. Additionally, 32% of these workers reported not having enough time to act on communications from headquarters, and 42% found the messages irrelevant.

Here’s How to Fix It:

• Simplify Communication Channels: Many frontline believe there’s no clear way to get important updates. Organizations should streamline safety communication into one easy-to-use channel for everyone.
• Make Messages Relevant and Timely: The same survey ⁽³⁾ revealed that 30% of workers believe internal communications actually get in the way of their work. To fix this, ensure safety messages are clear, actionable, and related to their tasks. Consider using microlearning platforms for regular safety training to share important information in small, easy-to-understand segments.
• Humanize Communication: Almost half of frontline workers say they don’t recognize the faces of HQ team members. Personalizing communication can build trust and engagement. Think about including short videos or images of leadership sharing safety updates to create a more connected workplace.

3. Underreporting or Misreporting of accidents

What It Looks Like:
Employees may avoid reporting accidents, near-misses, or safety concerns due to fear of retaliation, peer judgment, or lack of faith in the reporting system. This leads to unresolved safety risks and missed opportunities for improvement. A study found that 64% of workers have experienced an accident at work that went unreported. ⁽⁵⁾.

How to Fix It:

• Create a Safe Reporting Environment: Anonymity encourages reporting. Set up systems where employees can safely report incidents without fear of backlash.
• Transparent Follow-Up: Every incident reported should be followed up with clear communication on the actions being taken. This transparency builds trust in the reporting system, encouraging more employees to come forward with safety concerns.
• Use Data to Monitor Trends: Track the number and type of reports. If underreporting is suspected, conduct anonymous surveys to assess employee confidence in the safety culture. In environments with good reporting systems, near-miss reporting has been shown to reduce accidents by 64% ⁽⁶⁾ .

4. Lack of Employee Engagement = Poor Workplace Safety Culture

What It Looks Like:
When employees are disengaged, safety training sessions are seen as a formality rather than an opportunity to learn. This attitude results in a lack of vigilance in day-to-day tasks and can lead to dangerous shortcuts or ignorance of safety policies. There is a proven link between workplace safety and employee engagement with disengaged workers more prone to suffering injuries. A Gallup poll in the US reported that 64% more accidents ⁽⁸⁾ involve ‘disengaged workers’ than ‘engaged’ workers.

How to Fix It:

• Involve Employees in Safety Decisions: Conduct workshops or feedback sessions where employees can voice their concerns or suggest improvements. This involvement creates a sense of ownership in safety initiatives.
• Make training more engaging: Instead of using generic slide-based safety training, consider making it interactive and enjoyable. Incorporate storytelling, role-playing, or simulation-based training to better engage employees and help them grasp the importance of safety protocols. By making safety training more fun, you can effectively connect with your teams and foster a culture of safety.
• Remind, Repeat: To reinforce safety messages, use posters, digital reminders, and short, focused training modules. This approach makes it easy to repeat key points, helping to build good safety habits over time.

5. High Accident Rates

What It Looks Like:
High accident rates are a clear indicator of a weak safety culture. Whether the accidents are major or minor, their frequency shows that safety protocols aren’t being properly followed, enforced, or understood. Companies with high accident rates often face serious productivity losses. In the US, workplace injuries can cost businesses over $1,100 per employee each year ⁽⁷⁾ . It's essential for companies to recognize these signs and take proactive steps to improve safety practices.

How to Fix It:

• Root Cause Analysis: Investigate every accident or near-miss and determine the underlying causes. This will not only address the immediate concern but also reveal systemic issues that can be corrected to prevent future incidents.
• Ongoing Safety Audits: Regularly audit safety procedures and equipment to ensure they are up to date and functioning properly.
• Safety Incentive Programs: Implement programs that reward employees for maintaining a clean safety record. Recognition and rewards, even for small safety victories, can lead to an increase in overall safety engagement.

Conclusion A weak safety culture endangers employees and results in significant financial costs through accidents, downtime, legal penalties, and decreased morale. Addressing leadership buy-in, communication, underreporting, engagement, and accident prevention can significantly improve workplace safety and create a positive, lasting impact. With the right approach, safety won’t just be a policy; it will become a shared value across your entire organization

At YOUFactors, we are dedicated to helping organizations build a better safety culture by focusing on habit formation. Our platform fosters safer habits, encourages empathy among employees, and reduces human errors by working on innate safety behaviors. By integrating YOUFactors into your safety strategy, you can create a more proactive and engaged workforce, leading to fewer accidents and a stronger overall safety culture. Ready to make a change? Book a demo with us to discover how YOUFactors can support your journey toward a safer workplace..


Sources:

• ‍_{(1) Assessing the Mediating Role of Safety Communication Between Safety Culture and Employees Safety Performance‍}
• _{(2) The Role of Safety Leadership and Safety Culture in improving Safety Performance‍}
• _{(3) Feedback From The Field: Communications need to catch up to the reality of frontline work‍}
• _{(4) Influence of communication determinants on safety commitment in a high-risk workplace: a systematic literature review of four communication dimensions‍}
• _{(5) The unreported reality: Do people know how to report an accident at work?‍}
• _{(6) Effectiveness of the Near Miss Safety Program Relative to the Total Number of Recordable Accidents‍}
• _{(7) Cost of Workplace Injuries & Accidents‍}
• _{(8) U.S. Employee Engagement Reverts Back to Pre-COVID-19 Levels}

_‍